A Flawed Mirror *

          One night toward the end of 1966 I spent an hour or two with R. (Robert) Crumb, the
    soon-to-be legendary cartoonist. I wasn’t yet sixteen; Crumb would have been around
    twenty-three. At that time he was married to a girl named Dana Morgan, and the two of them
    were poised to shake the dust of Cleveland forever from their heels. An iconic Crumb
    drawing from the Keep On Truckin’ period shows him as he saw himself then, scrawny and
    nerdy, levitating toward San Francisco’s Haight-Ashbury district. Exuberant proto-hippie
    chicks and unfettered expression beckoned him on, an unlikely recruit to the shagadelic
    armies of the Summer of Love. But at that moment in 1966 he was winding up a stint at
    American Greetings, drawing user-friendly greeting cards under the direction of his boss
    Tom Wilson (later of Ziggy fame).  As it happened Dana’s brother was a guy I’d known since
    kindergarten. For some unknown reason it occurred to him to invite me over to his brother-
    in-law’s to check out his cartoons.
          Robert and Dana lived in a seedy-looking apartment on Carnegie Avenue. Of course
    none of us knew that some of the sketchbooks I saw that night would be traded, much later,
    for a villa in the south of France, where the artist still lives with his second wife Aline
    Kominsky-Crumb. If Crumb were to revisit his old University Circle haunts now he could draw
    a satisfyingly ironic scene: the building was demolished sometime in the late 1970’s and the
    lot is a City Side Park. Across Stokes Boulevard the venerable Tudor Arms Hotel has
    become headquarters for the Cleveland Job Corps. Two blocks away the site of the 1960’s
    club La Cave, where Odetta and Bob Seeger and Tom Paxton performed, has been
    consumed by the ever-voracious Cleveland Clinic, as have all signs that this general area
    was once a haven for beatniks like Crumb. I suppose the true-blue beats and Crumb
    himself would be relieved at the absence of commemorative plaques.
          Crumb’s place was sparsely furnished, orderly and clean. The artist wore his trademark
    heavy-rimmed glasses, but I remember him as far more prepossessing than his self-
    caricatures. Clean-shaven and painfully thin, he had a touch of draughtsman scoliosis and
    a vaguely fanatical pallor – a romantic figure in his way. We sat on something Danish-
    modern and drank tea. Presently Crumb brought out a pile of notebook-size comics and
    sketches from an adjoining room, including his Fritz the Cat books. They weren't published
    yet, so these were the hand-inked and colored originals.
          Considering the standard, off-the-drugstore-shelf size of the hundreds of panels, the
    detail and expressiveness of Crumb’s drawings were astounding. And as R. Crumb readers
    everywhere have known for the past forty years, that was the least of it. Fritz was scruffily
    cute, but as storylines progressed and the tomcat’s striped tie worked its way out of
    alignment, his leers, fears, and sgtoned enthusiasms grew to be larger than life. Fritz was a
    combination of cool cat and middle-class kid, often out of his depth in pursuit of such urban
    desiderata as booze, drugs, and sleazeball gal-animals of various species. Elaborate
    paranoid fantasies played themselves out, complete with crowd scenes and political
    subplots. Racism, drug addiction, urban blight, and the cold war were among the elements
    of a nightmare vision of contemporary life unlike anything I’d ever seen. These were on no
    sense cartoons as I had experienced them. There were echoes of Pogo, Lil Abner, Little
    Lulu, and Dick Tracy. Dr. Seuss, early Disney, maybe even the Katzenjammer Kids were
    buried somewhere in the prehistory of Crumb’s dynamic, densely crosshatched depictions.
    But such associations only underscored the sheer squalor of Crumb’s powerful vision.
    Crumb’s demented narratives rolled along, collecting a weight of pessimism heavy enough
    to crush the unwary reader.
          Like any kid raised in the 1950s and 60s I was familiar with the closest precursor to
    Crumb’s work. No sleepover or school locker was complete without a few tattered issues of
    Harvey Kurtzman’s Mad Magazine. I learned later that Crumb had actually worked as
    Kurtzman’s assistant on another zine of the period called Help! Along with the future Monty
    Python celeb Terry Gilliam. Not even the scrofulous adolescent skepticism of Mad, however,
    could compare with Crumb’s hot pursuit of moral decay.
           Within two years his imagery was everywhere. The cartoon cover for Janis Joplin’s
    Cheap Thrills album was as unavoidable as Sgt. Pepper. Crumb’s Zap Comix character Mr.
    Natural was right up there with the Maharishi as one of the counterculture’s most high-
    profile bogus spiritual advisors. As for Fritz, in 1970 he became the subject of Ralph Bakshi’
    s trashy X-rated feature-length movies Fritz the Cat, Parts One and Two (Crumb was so
    disgusted with the cat thing he eventually had Fritz murdered with an ice pick). More
    recently the weirdly excellent 1995 movie Crumb, directed by Crumb family friend Terry
    Swigoff, made a flash in film circles.
          In the intervening decades Crumb has continued to produce a vast swamp of images,
    from the first irascible issue of Harvey Pekar’s American Splendor to his own ongoing
    autobiographical cartoon series titled Self Loathing; his Rapudiograph has eben in constant
    motion since early childhood, when his older brother Charles bullied him into illustrating
    Treasure Island for his own obsessive sexual reasons. Lately, living in the French town of
    Sauve, Crumb has spent a lot of time at restaurants, usually in the company of friends; he
    passes the time by sketching these people, and whatever else comes to mind, on
    placemats. So far two volumes of placemat drawinsg have appeared in print under the title
    Waiting for Food.
          A recent exhibit at Daniel Weinberg Gallery in Los Angeles is made up largely of a
    selection of these drawings, supplemented by a random group of book cover illustrations
    and sketches. Whether or not Crumb has mellowed, the unedgy works at Weinberg are first
    of all notable for their charm. There are studies of his wife Aline decked out in haute
    couture gowns and shoes that appeared on the pages of the New York Times, poignant
    depictions of his buddy Charles Bukowski, and a few earlier works still in the artist’s
    possession. The placemat pieces in particular are intriguing. The quirkiness of Crumb’s off-
    the-cuff preoccupations becomes tinged with melancholy, as one realizes they are so
    clearly the memories and reflections of an ex-patriot. Some depict music legends like The
    Notorious Genna Brothers strumming their banjos, or 1940’s cowboy singer Al Dexter. In
    Crumb’s half-length version the late great Dexter holds a guitar and squints stonily, his
    psychopathic sang froid shading the title of that hit number “Pistol Packin’ Mama.” Hanging
    nearby, a masterful study of Fanny Brice reminds us how remarkable a portraitist Crumb
    can be. A small drawing of a mildly disaffected cat, Bernie in the Morning Wanting Some
    Attention, stretches its paw at us, recreating a private moment even as it inevitably recalls
    Fritz – who was once Fred, Crumb’s childhood pet. On another wall I was surprised to find a
    late 1960’s-era portrait of Dana Morgan, looking very much as she did the night I met her.
          Everything is unmistakably, irredeemably Crumb, whose eye and hand are like a
    deliberately flawed mirror. The quality of caricature has become merely an inevitable
    condition of Crumb’s drawings, a stylistic burden that recalls his very public and influential
    presence. But whether despite or on account of being so exaggeratedly egocentric in this
    way, Crumb’s most casual drawings (like Daumier’s, or Goya’s) convey an immediate, vivid
    relationship to their subjects. Crumb’s hard-won, endlessly articulated subjectivity remakes
    the world as if on stage, playing to all our fabrications in the shrouded comic pages of the
    brain.


    [first published in Angle: a Journal of Arts + Culture, June, 2003]


   *winner of Cleveland Press Club Excellence in Journalism Award, 1994